A correction from the teaser for this item, the cost is around $29K, not $30K. Call it a rounding error.
Supt. Jackie Krause introduced this item by saying that the current phone system is 5 years old, and has had one hard drive failure. There is no backup system for the phone system or any messages left. The cost to upgrade the software alone is$6500.
The new system will have the software upgrade plus a new server, backup capability, one number for the public to dial, and will be using Voice Over Internet Protocol (VOIP) using wireless access in the village. Dr. Krause also intends for the district to recoup the costs by leasing extra bandwidth to the village and the library.
Dr. Krause said the current system, which uses a T1 line, costs the district $17K, but that Brian Sawyer has negotiated this down to $15K. She says the current T1 line is slow, especially during peak hours. Sawyer said that current speeds can get to 1.5M in the Middle School, and around 400K at ARS. The issue is that when the system gets a lot of traffic, the phones get priority over internet usage.
Board Member Steve Knar noted that a lot of businesses run on 300K of bandwidth. He asked whether the district should encourage parents to use e-mail rather than call the schools whenever possible. Dr. Krause said that parents prefer to call the school instead.
Former Board Member Don Rose attended the meeting to describe the new phone system as a representative for the company doing the new phone system. In response to current Board Member Tom Mollet's comment that the fire signal uses a T1 line, Rose said that SBC (now AT&T) has a dedicated circuit for alarms that cannot be removed.
Rose went on to say that with the increase in internet capacity, that voice mail could be delivered via e-mail. In response to current Board Member Pat Hughes' question about how reliable the wireless access would be, Rose said that the system would have a standard phone line backup. He also said that the system should be installed over the summer to keep from impacting the school year, and that it should be done this summer because the current contracts are up for renewal.
After current Board Member Bob Nunamaker noted that much of the cost savings would be realized by the district because of Sawyer's negotiation of the T1 costs, and would not be a part of installing a new phone system, Dr. Krause emphasized the features of the new system. She said that the district would be able to back up e-mail, while Dr. Tim Mahaffy said that the district would be able to track down voice messages and identify prank callers. Dr. Krause also said the new system would be able to automatically dial homes with pre-recorded messages to alert parents of snow days during the school year.
Knar responded that he felt the district was going for the "Cadillac phone system," and asked if all of these features were really needed in order to serve the district. He said that the Board will have to explain why it's spending $29K on a phone system when the savings are effective over 5 years. He said the district is putting a lot of money out up front, but only getting a trickle back.
Knar then asked if this project was going to a single vendor, and Dr. Krause replied that it was. Knar asked if the Board can do a $29K expense to a single vendor, and Dr. Krause replied yes, because it is an upgrade to an existing system.
Former Board Member Don Rose said that the library could contribute $3K, plus a portion of the phone bill. Current Board Member Bob Nunamaker said, since the district is concerned about its cash flow, they should consider leasing the system. Dr. Krause replied that the phone system would be paid for in FY07. Rose said that a lease would cost around $600 per month over 5 years. Knar replied that the disadvantage is that the district would need a new phone system in 5 years. Rose noted that in 5 years the system would likely be obsolete, since the lease does not include software upgrades. That would require a separate service contract.
In the end, neither Knar nor Nunamaker were swayed to buy the system, but the motion to buy the system passed anyway, even though only two Board Members voted for it. You see, the meeting was not well attended; President Paula Zasadil, Vice-President Doris Sadik, and Board Member Gerry Blohm were absent. Only Nunamaker, Knar, Mollet, and Hughes attended the meeting. Mollet and Hughes voted for the new phone system, Nunamaker voted against it.
One of Knar's concerns was that the full Board was not in attendance to hear and vote on the proposal, and he argued to have the discussion tabled to the next meeting. But Don Rose thought that might delay the installation of the system, if it were approved, and impact the school year. Mollet and Hughes voted in favor of the system, Nunamaker voted against it, but Knar chose to abstain from the vote, thus allowing the motion to pass on a vote of 2-1.
And so, with the official approval of only two Board Members, District 3 will get a new, $29K phone system.